SingHealth Breach Post-mortem: Key Findings

SingHealth Breach Post-mortem: Key Findings
Rafael Amado
Read More From Rafael Amado
January 29, 2019 | 5 Min Read

On 10 January 2019, Singaporean authorities finally released a report detailing how the attack against Singapore’s largest group of healthcare organizations, SingHealth, occurred. The breach took place between August 2017 and July 2018, resulting in the compromise of 1.5 million patient records, including personally identifiable information (PII) such as medical records, prescriptions, full names, National Registration Identity Card (NRIC) numbers, addresses, and dates of birth. In our last extended edition of ShadowTalk, Dr Richard Gold joined me to discuss the implications of the report.

 

What happened?

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the attackers did not use a dreaded zero-day exploit for initial intrusion. Early reports suggested the attack started through a phishing attempt. The authors of the final report said they were unable to nail down the initial vector; however, they also suspected it was phishing.  

One compelling hypothesis doing the rounds on social media is that the attackers achieved their intrusion through an open source penetration-testing toolkit called Ruler. Here the attackers seemingly targeted a known vulnerability that SingHealth had failed to patch. This vulnerability allowed the attacker to modify a user’s Microsoft Outlook homepage. Armed with credentials, the attackers feasibly could have logged in to Outlook Exchange as that user and set their Outlook to be a piece of malicious code. If this hypothesis is true, then in essence this is a fully-remote attack conducted using Ruler, rather than a phishing attempt.

Another point to note is that the attackers were in the network for at least a year. Once they broke in, they then laid dormant for several months before moving laterally within the network and accessing the medical database they were after.  


How might attackers use the stolen data?

The post-mortem report states that personal and outpatient data belonging to Singaporean Prime Minister, Lee Hsien Loong, was repeatedly targeted and accessed, which indicates there may be a political aspect to this attack. Nevertheless, with over 1.5 million records stolen, other motives beyond political-espionage need to also be considered.

If we think of how this data can be monetized, the detailed personal data included in the database can be used for financial purposes such filing fraudulent tax returns, or credit card and loan applications. With this amount of detailed information on an individual, you can effectively authenticate as another person. If combined with other datasets such as travel records or hotel stays – as seen in the Marriott breach – then this could be significant from a counter-intelligence perspective. There is therefore an overlap here between political-espionage and financial uses for the data.

 

Was this the work of an APT group?

Attributing attacks to Advanced Persistent Threat (APT) groups is fashionable, and we generally look at such claims with a degree of skepticism. In this case, however, there does appear to be some truth in it.

If we look at characteristics of the attack, the level of persistence displayed by the attackers fits the profile of an APT group. The attackers accessed a Citrix virtualization environment that allows you to connect to backend databases, including ones holding medical data. Here the attacker was able to gain access to the Citrix environment through credential reuse, but once they got in, there were a number of different servers and not all of these had the access they required. They tried numerous ways to access these and it is this tenacity that demonstrated the attackers had a goal – or set of goals – which they were clearly very motivated to achieve. In other words, they moved around the environment until they obtained the credentials they needed and the appropriate server to access the medical database.  

This does not appear to be an opportunistic attack: for example, one where the attackers hoover up everything and anything they can find. Instead they specifically wanted access to a particular database. In the end, all these different attempts were what alerted the administrators that something suspicious was happening.

 

What are the main points security teams should take away from this report?

There are both technical and process failures here that we should pay attention to. On the technical side, we saw known vulnerabilities being exploited when patches were available. The organization had recently employed penetration testers whose findings were ignored. The tests addressed a lack of network segmentation (which allowed attackers to move laterally), and no multi-factor authentication for administrator accounts. 

With regards to process, two key findings stand out. First, the report authors judged that the staff didn’t have the appropriate cyber security awareness or resources to respond effectively to the attack. While they picked up the activity, they didn’t understand it in the context of what APT attacks looks like, which severely limited how they could respond.

The second point is that key security personnel (those in charge of IT, security, incident response, and reporting) failed to take timely action. Put another way, those making decisions didn’t make any decisions. Something as significant as the Prime Minister’s medical records being repeatedly targeted and stolen should have been escalated to the Singaporean Cyber Security Agency (CSA), which has a background in APT activity. The security management personnel in question did not seem to know what a security incident was or how to respond. For example, they made unrealistic demands such as needing 100 percent confidence that it was malicious activity (you are never 100 percent sure until it’s too late). Even more alarmingly, they were reluctant to escalate the issue in case it was a false alarm and it would not reflect well on them.

 

For more analysis of the SingHealth breach post-mortem report, listen to the full episode of ShadowTalk: Episode 57: Singapore Healthcare Breach.

 

To stay up to date with the latest in digital risk protection, subscribe to our threat intelligence emails here.

Access Our Threat Intel In Test Drive

Test Drive SearchLight Free for 7 Days
Try It Now

Connect with us

Related Posts

Cybersecurity Awareness Month: Week 2 – Security Devices at Home and Work

Cybersecurity Awareness Month: Week 2 – Security Devices at Home and Work

October 14, 2020 | 7 Min Read

This week, National Cyber Security Awareness...
Clickbait to Checkmate: SMS-based scam targets US smartphones and accesses victim locations

Clickbait to Checkmate: SMS-based scam targets US smartphones and accesses victim locations

October 13, 2020 | 11 Min Read

Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic,...
Help your development teams keep their keys safe

Help your development teams keep their keys safe

October 7, 2020 | 3 Min Read

Modern development practices are a blessing...
Four Ways to Validate Credentials in SearchLight

Four Ways to Validate Credentials in SearchLight

September 29, 2020 | 3 Min Read

Amid the billions of credentials that are...
Access Keys Exposed: More Than 40% Are For Database Stores

Access Keys Exposed: More Than 40% Are For Database Stores

September 14, 2020 | 6 Min Read

By now, we’ve all heard news about AWS...
Validate Exposed Credentials with Okta to Save Even More Time

Validate Exposed Credentials with Okta to Save Even More Time

August 24, 2020 | 3 Min Read

SearchLight customers can now automatically...
Account takeover: Expanding on impact

Account takeover: Expanding on impact

July 27, 2020 | 7 Min Read

Digital Shadows has collected over 15 billion...
SearchLight’s Credential Validation: Only Focus on What Matters

SearchLight’s Credential Validation: Only Focus on What Matters

July 14, 2020 | 4 Min Read

Of the many use cases associated with threat...
Reducing technical leakage: Detecting software exposure from the outside-in

Reducing technical leakage: Detecting software exposure from the outside-in

June 16, 2020 | 6 Min Read

Modern Development Practices Leads to...
The 2020 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report: One CISO’s View

The 2020 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report: One CISO’s View

May 19, 2020 | 6 Min Read

Sadly, Marvel’s Black Widow release date was...
A NEW DECADE OF CYBER THREATS: LOOKING BACK AT THE TRENDING CYBER TOPICS OF Q1 2020

A NEW DECADE OF CYBER THREATS: LOOKING BACK AT THE TRENDING CYBER TOPICS OF Q1 2020

May 14, 2020 | 10 Min Read

Q1 2020 was packed full of significant...
How to minimize cybersecurity breaches in 2020

How to minimize cybersecurity breaches in 2020

April 8, 2020 | 9 Min Read

Seriously, don’t click back or close – I...
COVID-19: Third-party risks to businesses

COVID-19: Third-party risks to businesses

March 31, 2020 | 5 Min Read

As social distancing becomes more prevalent...
Threat Model of a Remote Worker

Threat Model of a Remote Worker

March 25, 2020 | 7 Min Read

Threat models are an often discussed but...
Want to Control Your Ever-Changing Perimeter? Focus on Integrations.

Want to Control Your Ever-Changing Perimeter? Focus on Integrations.

March 4, 2020 | 5 Min Read

An ever changing perimeter? Over the past few...
How Digital Shadows Helped Find and Remediate an Exposed Admin Password on Github

How Digital Shadows Helped Find and Remediate an Exposed Admin Password on Github

January 23, 2020 | 5 Min Read

  I often get asked to share examples of...
Third Party Risk: 4 ways to manage your security ecosystem

Third Party Risk: 4 ways to manage your security ecosystem

January 16, 2020 | 5 Min Read

  The digital economy has multiplied the...
2020 Cybersecurity Forecasts: 5 trends and predictions for the new year

2020 Cybersecurity Forecasts: 5 trends and predictions for the new year

December 18, 2019 | 10 Min Read

  If all the holiday fuss isn’t...
2.3 billion files exposed across online file storage technologies

2.3 billion files exposed across online file storage technologies

December 3, 2019 | 17 Min Read

Originally published May 2019 2.3 billion is a...
Understanding the Consequences of Data Leakage through History

Understanding the Consequences of Data Leakage through History

October 24, 2019 | 4 Min Read

One of the most interesting aspects of...
Honeypots: Tracking Attacks Against Misconfigured or Exposed Services

Honeypots: Tracking Attacks Against Misconfigured or Exposed Services

October 17, 2019 | 9 Min Read

Honeypots can be useful tools for gathering...
ANU Breach Report: Mapping to Mitre ATT&CK Framework

ANU Breach Report: Mapping to Mitre ATT&CK Framework

October 11, 2019 | 14 Min Read

Introduction This week, the Australian National...
DevSecOps: Continued Database Exposures Point to Growing Challenges

DevSecOps: Continued Database Exposures Point to Growing Challenges

September 24, 2019 | 5 Min Read

Last week, we learned that millions of...
Your Data at Risk: FBI Cyber Division Shares Top Emerging Cyber Threats to Your Enterprise

Your Data at Risk: FBI Cyber Division Shares Top Emerging Cyber Threats to Your Enterprise

September 17, 2019 | 8 Min Read

Data breaches are not slowing down. Nobody...
Capital One Breach: What we know and what you can do

Capital One Breach: What we know and what you can do

July 31, 2019 | 5 Min Read

Monday blues. It’s a thing. It’s when you...
Harnessing Exposed Data to Enhance Cyber Intelligence

Harnessing Exposed Data to Enhance Cyber Intelligence

July 11, 2019 | 7 Min Read

  An illicit and lucrative trade has...
Leaky SMB File Shares – So Many Bytes!

Leaky SMB File Shares – So Many Bytes!

June 19, 2019 | 5 Min Read

Everyone loves a sequel. If you’re an avid...
Managing Digital Risk: 4 Steps to Take

Managing Digital Risk: 4 Steps to Take

June 18, 2019 | 9 Min Read

Organizations are finding it increasingly...
Enabling Soi Dog’s Digital Transformation: A Case Study

Enabling Soi Dog’s Digital Transformation: A Case Study

May 8, 2019 | 3 Min Read

At the beginning of this year I was introduced to...
Reducing your attack surface

Reducing your attack surface

April 9, 2019 | 4 Min Read

What is an attack surface According to OWASP, an...
Detecting Exposed Company Data: The What, Why, and How

Detecting Exposed Company Data: The What, Why, and How

March 12, 2019 | 3 Min Read

What is data loss detection? A fundamental...
Introducing Our Practical Guide to Reducing Digital Risk

Introducing Our Practical Guide to Reducing Digital Risk

February 12, 2019 | 5 Min Read

Download a copy of A Practical Guide to Reducing...
Understanding Digital Risk Protection

Understanding Digital Risk Protection

February 8, 2019 | 3 Min Read

There has been a lot of talk recently about...
Law Firm Uncovers Exposed Sensitive Details About Top Attorney Online

Law Firm Uncovers Exposed Sensitive Details About Top Attorney Online

November 15, 2018 | 2 Min Read

VIPs and executives who are critical to your...
81,000 Hacked Facebook Accounts for Sale: 5 Things to Know

81,000 Hacked Facebook Accounts for Sale: 5 Things to Know

November 2, 2018 | 5 Min Read

This morning, the British Broadcasting...
Cyber Security Awareness Month: Week 1 – Credential Hygiene

Cyber Security Awareness Month: Week 1 – Credential Hygiene

October 3, 2018 | 5 Min Read

It’s the opening week of the annual National...
GAO’s Equifax Post-mortem Report

GAO’s Equifax Post-mortem Report

September 11, 2018 | 5 Min Read

It’s common for the exciting and novel issues...
Digital Shadows Contributes to Insider Threat Research

Digital Shadows Contributes to Insider Threat Research

August 9, 2018 | 5 Min Read

On July 30, Forrester published its latest...
Reducing Your Attack Surface: From a Firehose to a Straw

Reducing Your Attack Surface: From a Firehose to a Straw

July 5, 2018 | 6 Min Read

What is Attack Surface Reduction? Attack Surface...
Keys to the Kingdom: Exposed Security Assessments

Keys to the Kingdom: Exposed Security Assessments

April 24, 2018 | 4 Min Read

Organizations employ external consultants and...
Out In The Open: Corporate Secrets Exposed Through Misconfigured Services

Out In The Open: Corporate Secrets Exposed Through Misconfigured Services

April 18, 2018 | 4 Min Read

For organizations dealing with proprietary...
When There’s No Need to Hack: Exposed Personal Information

When There’s No Need to Hack: Exposed Personal Information

April 17, 2018 | 4 Min Read

With Equifax‘s breach of 145 million records...
Leveraging the 2018 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report

Leveraging the 2018 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report

April 10, 2018 | 5 Min Read

Today, the 11th edition of the Verizon Data...
When Sharing Is Not Caring: Over 1.5 Billion Files Exposed Through Misconfigured Services

When Sharing Is Not Caring: Over 1.5 Billion Files Exposed Through Misconfigured Services

April 5, 2018 | 4 Min Read

Our recent report “Too Much Information”,...
Ransomware in 2018: 4 Things to Look Out For

Ransomware in 2018: 4 Things to Look Out For

March 8, 2018 | 4 Min Read

Ransomware remains an active threat for...
Data Privacy Day: 8 Key Recommendations for GDPR Readiness

Data Privacy Day: 8 Key Recommendations for GDPR Readiness

January 26, 2018 | 4 Min Read

This Sunday is Data Privacy Day, “an...
Don’t Rely on One Star to Manage Digital Risk, The Key is Total Coverage

Don’t Rely on One Star to Manage Digital Risk, The Key is Total Coverage

January 16, 2018 | 5 Min Read

This post originally appeared on...
GDPR: Why You Need to Consider the Personal Data That Lies Outside of Your Organization

GDPR: Why You Need to Consider the Personal Data That Lies Outside of Your Organization

January 4, 2018 | 3 Min Read

In 2010, reports emerged that the Information...
GDPR – Not Just a European Concern

GDPR – Not Just a European Concern

November 20, 2017 | 6 Min Read

This post originally appeared...
Why “Have a Safe Trip” Is Taking On Greater Meaning

Why “Have a Safe Trip” Is Taking On Greater Meaning

November 14, 2017 | 5 Min Read

This post originally appeared...
equifax research report

2017 Equifax Breach: Impact and Lessons Learned

September 28, 2017 | 3 Min Read

Equifax experienced a data breach that occurred...
equifax breach update

An Update on the Equifax Data Breach

September 13, 2017 | 8 Min Read

The credit reporting agency Equifax...
Equifax Breach Assessment

Equifax Breach: The Impact For Enterprises and Consumers

September 8, 2017 | 9 Min Read

What we know about the Equifax breach On...
Credential Exposure Data Loss Blog

Bitglass: Compromised Credentials are Just One Way Your Corporate Data is Being Exposed

August 18, 2017 | 2 Min Read

A guest blog from Bitglass, read the original...
NIST Authentication

Authentication Nation: 5 Ways NIST is Changing How We Think About Passwords

May 9, 2017 | 4 Min Read

Passwords have taken a beating over the past...
Brand Reputation Digital Risk

The 3 Pillars of Digital Risk Management: Part 3 – The Top 5 Main Risks of Reputational Damage

April 27, 2017 | 2 Min Read

In this 3-part blog series, we discuss how each...
Cyber Threats

The 3 Pillars of Digital Risk Management: Part 1 Understanding Cyber Threats

April 13, 2017 | 3 Min Read

What is Digital Risk Management? The National...
Five Tips To Make Your Passwords Better

Five Tips To Make Your Passwords Better

September 26, 2016 | 4 Min Read

While security is everyone’s responsibility,...
breached data

The Industrialized Uses of Breached Data

September 21, 2016 | 4 Min Read

In our first blog, we outlined a number of...
credential compromise

Beauty and the Breach: Leaked Credentials in Context

September 21, 2016 | 4 Min Read

Our analysts recently researched credential...
New report: 97 percent of the top 1,000 companies suffer from credential compromise

New report: 97 percent of the top 1,000 companies suffer from credential compromise

September 20, 2016 | 2 Min Read

Data breaches and credential compromise are not...
Shadow Brokers

Four Things We’ve Learned From the Alleged Equation Group Code Leak

August 22, 2016 | 4 Min Read

The wake of the deeply bizarre auction of...
Wall of Sheep

Gambling with Security in Vegas: Not Your Best Bet

July 27, 2016 | 4 Min Read

With BSides Las Vegas, Black Hat, and DEF CON...
thedarkoverlord

Thedarkoverlord – losing his patients?

July 26, 2016 | 4 Min Read

In late June 2016, we observed a spate of attacks...
breach disclosure

5 Key Lessons From The FDIC’s Breach Disclosure Debacle

July 18, 2016 | 4 Min Read

Last week, the United States House Science, Space...
thedarkoverlord

10 ways to prepare for credential leak incidents

June 30, 2016 | 2 Min Read

From LinkedIn to MySpace, threat actors like...
OpAfrica

Data breaches targeting financial services: 2016 so far

May 26, 2016 | 3 Min Read

It’s been a busy year for data breaches...
Bozkurt Hackers

Bozkurt Hackers continue to leak bank data

May 13, 2016 | 4 Min Read

A threat actor calling itself “Bozkurt...
DBIR

Analyzing the 2016 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report

May 2, 2016 | 4 Min Read

Last week Verizon released the 2016 Data Breach...
Hacking Team

The Hacking Team breach – an attacker’s point of view

April 22, 2016 | 3 Min Read

On 17 April 2016, two posts were added to...
ransomware

Emerging Markets: Online Extortion Matures via DDoS Attacks

November 9, 2015 | 5 Min Read

Unlike scenes from books or movies where shadowy...
TalkTalk

TalkTalk: Avoiding The Hype

October 28, 2015 | 4 Min Read

There has been no shortage of media coverage on...
Adult Friend Finder

The Adult Friend Finder Breach: A Recap

September 7, 2015 | 5 Min Read

27th May 2015: Last week, news quickly...
Al Hayat

Saudi Arabia MOFA Breach

September 7, 2015 | 5 Min Read

Introduction As of April 2015 there were more...